The Energy Collective

The world's best thinkers on energy and climate

  • Home
  • Post Here
  • Columns
    • Electricity Markets & Policy Group
    • Full Spectrum
    • Energy and Policy Developments
    • Game Changers
    • Energy for Human Development
    • Seeking Consensus
    • Green Growth
    • New Energy Voices
  • Fuels
    • Oil
    • Wind
    • Nuclear Power
    • Coal
    • Natural Gas
    • Solar Power
    • Renewables
    • Biofuels
    • Geothermal Energy
    • Wave & Tidal
    • Hydro Power
  • Environment
    • Carbon and De-carbonization
    • International Climate Conferences
    • Sustainability
    • Climate
    • Public Health
    • Water
    • Recycling
  • Grid
    • Smart Grid
    • Electricity
  • Tech
    • Cleantech
    • Green Building
    • Storage
    • Rare Earth Minerals
  • Business and Economy
    • Cap-and-Trade
    • Agriculture
    • Efficiency
    • Green Business
    • Utilities
    • Finance
    • Green Jobs
    • Subsidies
    • Risk Management
  • Politics
    • Environmental Policy
    • Energy Security
    • Communications and Messaging
    • China
  • Transport
  • Help
    • FAQ
  • Account
    • Login
    • Register

Will Google Play By Utility Privacy Rules?

February 4, 2014 by Christine Hertzog

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

January 28, 2014 was Data Privacy Day.  Two recent news stories – the thefts of sensitive consumer data from national retailers including Target and Google’s $3.2B acquisition of smart thermostat maker Nest are stimulating much-needed discussion about the security and privacy of personal data. Security and privacy are inextricably linked. In the active criminal investigations underway, authorities will examine the involved parties’ security protections from both of these angles.  We may discover that complacency and failures of imagination were unwitting accomplices to criminal entities.  Let’s not be similar accomplices to weakening our energy data privacy protections.

The USA enacted the Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA 2007) that spurred much of the Smart Grid policies and activities ongoing today.  This legislation acknowledged that smart meters could create new energy data and the need for policies to protect this new data’s privacy.  Since then, Public Utility Commissions in various states have penned privacy guidelines that define what investor-owned utilities (IOUs) must do with energy data derived from smart meters.  For example, in the state of California, smart meter data is owned by the individual consumer (your meter, your data).  Whether that smart meter data remains with the utility or if the consumer authorizes it to be shared with a third party in the form of Green Button data, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) stated it will ensure equal regulatory treatment for third parties who acquire usage data from the utility via a smart meter or through an internet-connected device.

However rules like this do not apply to situations where consumers supply different energy use data directly to businesses.  This is the Nest scenario with their learning thermostat.  In this case, the thermostat gathers sufficient data about user temperature preferences correlated with time and activity sensors to make inferences about future heating and cooling preferences.  This is an “unregulated” peek inside the home at user behaviors.  A number of Nest customers are asking for ZigBeeR or Zwave connections to smart meters to leverage this data along with their learning thermostat data.  If Google/Nest were to do that, in states like California that could mean they would have to abide by the privacy rules governing utilities.

Consider the language of California’s AB 1274.  This bill prohibits the state’s IOUs and publicly-owned utilities “from sharing, disclosing, or otherwise making accessible to any 3rd party a customer’s electrical or natural gas usage data without obtaining the express consent of the customer and conspicuously disclosing to whom the disclosure will be made and how the data will be used. The bill would require a business and a nonaffiliated 3rd party, pursuant to a contract, to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices to protect the data from unauthorized disclosure. The bill would prohibit a business from providing an incentive or discount to the customer for accessing the data without the prior consent of the customer…”

Today, Nest has a privacy policy in place that states it would not provide consumer data to another third party without that consumer’s consent.  Read it.  It’s a reasonable policy, but as we’ve experienced before, privacy policies are subject to change without advance notice.

Nest is already dabbling in a demand response program called Rush Hour.  Google has had interests in energy management in the past.  It will be interesting to watch how this acquisition unfolds in terms of future energy services.  But if I was a California utility lawyer, I’d act like I’m from Missouri, the “show me” state and line up tough ßdisclosure requirements on how smart meter data is used if asked by Google/Nest to provide it.  And if I was a Nest customer, I wouldn’t be complacent – I’d be monitoring that Nest privacy page.

Photo Credit: Google, Nest, and Privacy/shutterstock

Related posts:

Google and Nest: The Big Picture for Home Automation Competitors ARPA-E ‘Encourages Crazy Ideas’ to Find Disruptive Energy Technology How One Industry Association Would Transform the Grid FERC Files Supreme Court Challenge to Demand Response Decision

Christine Hertzog

Filed Under: Cleantech, Communications and Messaging, Efficiency, Electricity, Energy, Energy and Economy, Energy Security, Green Business, News, Politics & Legislation, Risk Management, Tech, Utilities Tagged With: big data, google, nest thermostat, privacy

The Energy Collective Columns

Full Spectrum: Energy Analysis and Commentary with Jesse JenkinsEnergy and Policy Developments with John Miller
Game Changers column badgeEnergy for Human Development Column
Seeking Consensus with Schalk CloeteGreen Growth with Silvio Marcacci
New Energy VoicesMore coming soon...

Latest comments

  • EngineerPoet on Closing Nuclear Reactors in Ohio and Pennsylvania Will Thwart Climate Goals No demand shifts would have to be forced.  We are in a new regime where power prices can go to (April 19, 2018 at 6:34 PM)
  • BobMeinetz on Closing Nuclear Reactors in Ohio and Pennsylvania Will Thwart Climate Goals The issue is that wind & solar use thousands of small generators to supply 1GW. Hence sudden fai (April 19, 2018 at 5:58 PM)
  • BobMeinetz on Closing Nuclear Reactors in Ohio and Pennsylvania Will Thwart Climate Goals Sean, despite myths advanced by anti-nuclear activists, nuclear plants have been able to follow dema (April 19, 2018 at 5:46 PM)
  • BobMeinetz on This Cleantech Hotspot is Giving New York and California a Run for Their Money DIck, once again your comical sidestepping around the real reason Chicago is a clean energy leader - (April 19, 2018 at 5:24 PM)

Advisory Panel

About the panel

Scott Edward Anderson is a consultant, blogger, and media commentator who blogs at The Green Skeptic. More »


Christine Hertzog is a consultant, author, and a professional explainer focused on Smart Grid. More »


Elias Hinckley is a strategic advisor on energy finance and energy policy to investors, energy companies and governments More »


Gary Hunt Gary is an Executive-in-Residence at Deloitte Investments with extensive experience in the energy & utility industries. More »


Jesse Jenkins is a graduate student and researcher at MIT with expertise in energy technology, policy, and innovation. More »


Jim Pierobon helps trade associations/NGOs, government agencies and companies communicate about cleaner energy solutions. More »


Geoffrey Styles is Managing Director of GSW Strategy Group, LLC and an award-winning blogger. More »


Featured Contributors

Rod Adams

Scott Edward Anderson

Charles Barton

Barry Brook

Steven Cohen

Dick DeBlasio

Senator Pete Domenici

Simon Donner

Big Gav

Michael Giberson

Kirsty Gogan

James Greenberger

Lou Grinzo

Jesse Grossman

Tyler Hamilton

Christine Hertzog

David Hone

Gary Hunt

Jesse Jenkins

Sonita Lontoh

Rebecca Lutzy

Jesse Parent

Jim Pierobon

Vicky Portwain

Willem Post

Tom Raftery

Joseph Romm

Robert Stavins

Robert Stowe

Geoffrey Styles

Alex Trembath

Gernot Wagner

Dan Yurman

 

 

 

Follow Us

32-linkedin 32-facebook 32-twitter 32-rss

Content for personal use only. Distribution prohibited. Republication in part or in whole is strictly prohibited. © All rights reserved Energy Central © 2018

Recent Comments

  • EngineerPoet on Closing Nuclear Reactors in Ohio and Pennsylvania Will Thwart Climate Goals
  • BobMeinetz on Closing Nuclear Reactors in Ohio and Pennsylvania Will Thwart Climate Goals
  • BobMeinetz on Closing Nuclear Reactors in Ohio and Pennsylvania Will Thwart Climate Goals

Recent Posts

  • A Toolkit of Global Insights as China Builds Its Power Sector of the Future
  • $100 Oil Is Back On The Table
  • New Solar Capacity Exceeded All Other Fuel Sources Combined in 2017, Study Finds

Useful Pages

  • Terms of Use
  • Comments Policy
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • Help
  • About and Contact Us
Copyright © 2018 Energy Central. All Rights Reserved
This site uses cookies, for a number of reasons. By continuing to use this website you accept the use of cookies. Find out more.