The Energy Collective

The world's best thinkers on energy and climate

  • Home
  • Post Here
  • Columns
    • Electricity Markets & Policy Group
    • Full Spectrum
    • Energy and Policy Developments
    • Game Changers
    • Energy for Human Development
    • Seeking Consensus
    • Green Growth
    • New Energy Voices
  • Fuels
    • Oil
    • Wind
    • Nuclear Power
    • Coal
    • Natural Gas
    • Solar Power
    • Renewables
    • Biofuels
    • Geothermal Energy
    • Wave & Tidal
    • Hydro Power
  • Environment
    • Carbon and De-carbonization
    • International Climate Conferences
    • Sustainability
    • Climate
    • Public Health
    • Water
    • Recycling
  • Grid
    • Smart Grid
    • Electricity
  • Tech
    • Cleantech
    • Green Building
    • Storage
    • Rare Earth Minerals
  • Business and Economy
    • Cap-and-Trade
    • Agriculture
    • Efficiency
    • Green Business
    • Utilities
    • Finance
    • Green Jobs
    • Subsidies
    • Risk Management
  • Politics
    • Environmental Policy
    • Energy Security
    • Communications and Messaging
    • China
  • Transport
  • Help
    • FAQ
  • Account
    • Login
    • Register

NY Gov. Cuomo Reacts to Flawed Report on Earthquake Risk at Indian Point Nuclear Plant

March 22, 2011 by John Wheeler

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Bloomberg.com and other news outlets reported yesterday that NY Governor Andrew Cuomo is meeting with the NRC today in Washington DC to discuss the risk of earthquake damage at the Indian Point Nuclear Plant.  According to Bloomberg, the Governor’s concern was sparked by an MSNBC.com report that concluded Indian Point is the most likely nuclear plant in the USA to experience core damage and a release of radioactive contamination following an earthquake.

This is a perfect example of how erroneous news reports about nuclear energy never seem to die.  Even when such reports are refuted by multiple more qualified sources, politician still react.  Anti-nuclear groups are astute at using these flawed reports to support their calls for nuclear plants to shut down.  The details of this situation are contained in my letter to the editor of Bloomberg.com responsible for the story.  Here’s a copy:

My letter to Mr. Theo Mullen, Editor, Bloomberg.com News on March 22, 2011

Mr. Mullen,

Your story “New York, NRC Set to Meet About Indian Point Plant Safety“ that appeared yesterday on Bloomberg.com news missed some important facts that are highly relevant to the issue of safety at the Indian Point nuclear plant.

Concern by Gov. Cuomo and other NY officials over the earthquake risk at Indian Point was heightened when they learned that Indian Point Nuclear Plant is “at the top of the list” for earthquake risk in the USA.  The source of their heightened concern was a poorly researched report that first surfaced in this article by MSNBC.com: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/42103936/ns/world_news-asiapacific/.   This erroneous report was spread quickly by countless news organizations and anti-nuclear groups.

The story by MSNBC.com reporter Bill Dedman was fundamentally flawed; he misused and mischaracterized NRC data.  In addition, his article contained many gross inaccuracies.  In fact, the NRC, in a very uncharacteristically blunt manner, refuted Dedman’s inappropriate use of their data as was reported here:

http://www.dailytech.com/NuclearGate+US+NRC+Confirms+MSNBCcom+Reporter+Lied+Sensationalized+Story/article21170.htm

In summary, Gov. Cuomo’s concerns over earthquake risks at Indian Point are misplaced, and are the result of sloppy reporting and an overt attempt to sensationalize the risks.

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this story.

Sincerely,

John Wheeler

Producer, This Week in Nuclear

Related posts:

Mayor Bloomberg Draws The Line Against Closing Indian Point New York finds new reasons to litigate over Indian Point If Indian Point Nuclear Closes, Natural Gas Suppliers Profit Entergy to Refuel Vermont Yankee

John Wheeler

Producer of "This Week in Nuclear"; Manager in the Nuclear Industry; Former Senior Reactor Operator; Nuclear Workforce Planning & Workforce Development Expert

Filed Under: Nuclear Power Tagged With: Cuomo, indian point, new york, nrc, nuclear

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

The Energy Collective Columns

Full Spectrum: Energy Analysis and Commentary with Jesse JenkinsEnergy and Policy Developments with John Miller
Game Changers column badgeEnergy for Human Development Column
Seeking Consensus with Schalk CloeteGreen Growth with Silvio Marcacci
New Energy VoicesMore coming soon...

Latest comments

  • Bas Gresnigt on New Solar Capacity Exceeded All Other Fuel Sources Combined in 2017, Study Finds When all costs are accounted for, only the operating costs of nuclear power plants ($/MWh produced) (April 23, 2018 at 10:52 AM)
  • Sean on $100 Oil Is Back On The Table Apparently proofreading would help. I think I did it from my cell phone. "the cost of oil" is what (April 23, 2018 at 12:03 AM)
  • John Miller on Why EPA’s U-Turn on Auto Efficiency Rules Gives China the Upper Hand Claiming that China is becoming the World’s leader on pollution control somewhat distorts the impact (April 22, 2018 at 9:56 PM)
  • BobMeinetz on $100 Oil Is Back On The Table Agree, Sean. Greed, it turns out, may be a self-solving problem. (April 22, 2018 at 3:16 PM)

Advisory Panel

About the panel

Scott Edward Anderson is a consultant, blogger, and media commentator who blogs at The Green Skeptic. More »


Christine Hertzog is a consultant, author, and a professional explainer focused on Smart Grid. More »


Elias Hinckley is a strategic advisor on energy finance and energy policy to investors, energy companies and governments More »


Gary Hunt Gary is an Executive-in-Residence at Deloitte Investments with extensive experience in the energy & utility industries. More »


Jesse Jenkins is a graduate student and researcher at MIT with expertise in energy technology, policy, and innovation. More »


Jim Pierobon helps trade associations/NGOs, government agencies and companies communicate about cleaner energy solutions. More »


Geoffrey Styles is Managing Director of GSW Strategy Group, LLC and an award-winning blogger. More »


Featured Contributors

Rod Adams

Scott Edward Anderson

Charles Barton

Barry Brook

Steven Cohen

Dick DeBlasio

Senator Pete Domenici

Simon Donner

Big Gav

Michael Giberson

Kirsty Gogan

James Greenberger

Lou Grinzo

Jesse Grossman

Tyler Hamilton

Christine Hertzog

David Hone

Gary Hunt

Jesse Jenkins

Sonita Lontoh

Rebecca Lutzy

Jesse Parent

Jim Pierobon

Vicky Portwain

Willem Post

Tom Raftery

Joseph Romm

Robert Stavins

Robert Stowe

Geoffrey Styles

Alex Trembath

Gernot Wagner

Dan Yurman

 

 

 

Follow Us

32-linkedin 32-facebook 32-twitter 32-rss

Content for personal use only. Distribution prohibited. Republication in part or in whole is strictly prohibited. © All rights reserved Energy Central © 2018

Recent Comments

  • Bas Gresnigt on New Solar Capacity Exceeded All Other Fuel Sources Combined in 2017, Study Finds
  • Sean on $100 Oil Is Back On The Table
  • John Miller on Why EPA’s U-Turn on Auto Efficiency Rules Gives China the Upper Hand

Recent Posts

  • The Dangers of Green Technology-Forcing
  • Without Ambitious Energy Efficiency Goals, the EU Will Fail Paris Targets
  • Egypt’s $60 Billion Bet on Nuclear Energy

Useful Pages

  • Terms of Use
  • Comments Policy
  • Privacy & Cookies
  • Help
  • About and Contact Us
Copyright © 2018 Energy Central. All Rights Reserved
This site uses cookies, for a number of reasons. By continuing to use this website you accept the use of cookies. Find out more.